Do you have some more information like access, opening_hours or description of the location? just to tag de defibrillator is a good start but to gain helpful information, more information is needed.

Duplicate of node/13641202501. Please delete this node.

Changed in changeset/179986879

Hey habi
Es war ein Duplikat von node/13626520301. Der Tennisclub hat sich per Mail bei uns gemeldet.

Regarding the location and description, I think there's been a mistake here. Is this defibrillator really here? If so, could you describe the location in more detail? If not, I'd be grateful if you could provide the correct location.

Ah stimmt, gut gesehen. Merci :)

Hoi captain_slow
Wurden da absichtlich auch andere nodes wie z.B Defis entfernt? Oder wurden die wieder neu gemappt?

Can you please add more detailed information about this node? 24/7 available? Indoor? Access? Description of the location.

All this infos would be nice to have if you are in search for a defi.

Looks like a big mistake... can you please revert your changeset?

Which access Tag is in your opinion correct?
we will not disclose the reporting person to the public in the changesets.
what exactly will you delete? are you willing to talk to us in person?

we will take a look how we can improve the quality without canibalizing the user experience. thank you for your valuable input.

I deleted the mentioned node. we will take a look how we can improve the quality without canibalizing the user experience. thank you for your valuable input.

I agree.

done

for safety reasons i added this tag: be aware, access tag is recommended, not mandatory.

I deleted defibrillator:location as well because that was not the correct location.

access=yes seems legit during opening_hours. access is a little bit of a discussion in combination with AED. See: https://community.openstreetmap.org/t/access-no-auf-defibrillatoren-in-der-schweiz/118013

Please see: This entry seems reasonable to me. We take the focus on defis, not the world world around it, a missing container wouldn't be in our focus and we trust local osm communities/mappers to improve the map as well. The normal app/website user isn't an OSM user.
So how should we improv the OTG Rule? I quote "OSM data should, as far as is reasonably possible, be verifiable. The principle applies to tags and other aspects of data representation and essentially means another mapper should be able to come to the same place and collect the same data ("verify" the data you have entered). This principle excludes hypothetical or opinionated data like personal ratings."

It seems that this entry can be proved on point.
How would you do it, if you were us?

This entry seems reasonable to me. We take the focus on defis, not the world world around it, a missing container wouldn't be in our focus and we trust local osm communities/mappers to improve the map as well. The normal app/website user isn't an OSM user.
So how should we improv the OTG Rule? I quote "OSM data should, as far as is reasonably possible, be verifiable. The principle applies to tags and other aspects of data representation and essentially means another mapper should be able to come to the same place and collect the same data ("verify" the data you have entered). This principle excludes hypothetical or opinionated data like personal ratings."

It seems that this entry can be proved on point.
How would you do it, if you were us?

I called and asked about it. The defibrillator is located on the second floor of the building in one of the wards. So the location is correct. Why indoor=no was suddenly set there is beyond my knowledge. That also answers your question about the level.

But I would like to address one more point regarding putting in more effort. What specific suggestions for improvement do you have? We are open to any feedback and will try to implement it if possible.